OxBlog

Friday, September 16, 2005

# Posted 8:52 PM by Ariel David Adesnik  

BUSH WOULD KILL FOR THAT KIND OF PRESS COVERAGE: I think there is pretty strong agreement across the political spectrum that American journalists always make at least a token effort to ensure that both sides have their say in any given newspaper article. But actually, that's not that case.

Take a look at the article about Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad on page A26 of this morning's WaPo. The article is basically a summary of Ahmadinejad's press conference in New York. Even when he says things that are fairly absurd or insulting, you don't get a counterpoint from any of his critics, domestic or foreign.

Why is that? To some degree, I think that when you are a charter member of the Axis of Evil, journalists assume that no one will believe anything you say, so why take up space with a counterpoint?

The second reason is that Ahmadinejad himself is the implicit counterpoint to what we generally hear from the White House. He can say things like the United States "should not humiliate others, should not consider itself superior to others" because journalists possibly assume that their readers are already familiar with the opposing point of view.

What's interesting is that certain American politicians also benefit from this sort of treatment. If you turn to page C1 of this morning's Post, you can read about Rep. John Lewis' (D-GA) argument that John Roberts isn't fully aware of just how much blacks suffered as a result of Jim Crow. There are actually two brief quotes from Roberts supporters, but the article is 95% Lewis.

In this instance, you obviously can't say that readers will know not to trust what Lewis says. To the contrary, his status as a "civil rights icon" ensures that his argument will carry the presumption of truth. Yet since Roberts' confirmation is now pretty much beyond question, I think that perspectives such as Lewis have become implicit counterpoints, since the argument for Roberts is so well known.

Although Lewis comes pretty close to saying that white conservatives can't possibly be fair to black people, I don't care so much about the lack of balance there because the Roberts issue has already been decided. Plus, there are always lower standards for the 'C' section, even though its contents are often the same as the hard news in 'A'.

But I think it is profoundly irresponsible to give Mahmoud Ahmadinejad a free pass. The issue here isn't whether his cheapshots at the United States go unanswered. That's irrelevant. But any article about the Iranian government should also let us know about the ongoing efforts of the Iranian opposition to stop rampant human rights violations in Iran and bring down the clerical dictatorship.
(1) opinions -- Add your opinion

Comments:
I have a membership at free proxy list
I would like to share with you my lastest proxy list :
211.237.87.130:24764
210.221.85.151:15337
193.189.190.145:10389
213.17.91.170:15132
203.81.224.220:23251
203.223.132.227:10690
210.182.107.44:39348
204.116.233.98:29726
202.41.190.172:37663
195.24.35.156:42215
212.217.30.194:15293
210.182.107.20:31928
213.47.137.164:10222
216.133.219.135:31964
131.94.223.11:37703
202.83.174.107:13421
210.182.107.21:25702
210.182.107.15:36602
209.162.241.237:12923
210.182.107.43:19200
210.182.107.15:36242
210.182.107.32:28180
213.60.14.216:42417
218.111.100.145:9135
210.182.107.12:39294
217.218.200.131:26826
210.182.107.20:33574
201.35.156.74:13046
210.66.198.132:4390
217.218.250.51:23300
218.154.19.138:3262
218.188.239.134:33072
211.96.14.200:1805
202.110.54.146:19608
211.60.144.190:3497
218.255.140.15:15611
218.255.252.232:41365
218.19.250.50:39894
208.180.253.19:41104
210.101.102.250:22844
218.27.203.183:15282
208.180.249.98:17364
218.56.59.102:8666
218.255.78.239:17548
218.63.230.201:29223
211.161.102.142:14263
218.72.103.114:2326
218.7.89.208:31380
218.242.72.190:28165
218.146.206.215:27671
218.94.14.133:3099
213.254.69.63:23026
219.149.179.10:18262
218.89.21.69:2260
219.101.223.207:14640
219.108.176.221:18150
212.58.30.72:29909
218.38.15.6:40906
219.71.203.111:14152
218.55.104.61:12024
220.149.64.24:11170
 
Post a Comment


Home